| [1] < [7] [8] 9 > [10] |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-3 00:31 發表 真正的愛是無償的付出。不管是哪種愛。 我把你的論點以另一角度寫出來: 我喜歡一個女生,我為她付出了很多,但她都不理我。她算什麼,把她殺掉比較省事。 | |
1.people are punished because they have sinned? but according to the bible...today we are punished by death because adam and eve ate the damn fruit...what do you think if you lose your left arm tomorrow because your father touched a girl's boobs? 2. i don't only read "why god did such "ungodly" thing"...i also think about it...and the more i think about it...the more i find it hard to believe in what i have read... 3. yes...indeed....think before you comment things...think before you go telling people to believe in something... | |
yes...i do wonder why...punishment is suppose to be a method to correct mistakes...yet what god does is ETERNAL PUNISHMENT....which has no ability in what punishment should accomplish... "i bet your parents punish you when u steal right?.. because they love you.. no?" yes...but i don't think parents would punish their stealing child by chopping off his hands... | |
1. god love them. 2. they denied god's love. then i think christians are right....god is really at a high moral level and human beings cannot understand him....because for a "father" to kill his own child out of "love" is not right even with human moral standard... | |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-2 23:23 發表 i got plenty of examples if you guys need o yes , we need it , please show us , ThANKs  | |
原帖由 劈柴 於 2008-9-3 01:11 發表 3. yes...indeed....think before you comment things...thinkbefore you go telling people to believe in something...  smarter + cleverrer !!!  以 其人g道，[';台] 其人g身 原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-2 23:23 發表 [url=redirect.php?goto=findpost&pid=29352&ptid=2361] | |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-2 23:23 發表 (1) "seriously you guys.. have you really read the bible.. or understand itbefore you comment these things?" What makes you think that we have not read the bible nor understood it? (2) ".. you pull one verse out of the bibleand use it to attack the bible... " When you point to a piece of paper and say that it is purely white, if we can point to a tiny fade spot on that piece of paper, that is all we need to disprove your statement. When you folks say that the Bible is irerrant and all true, we only need to point to an inconsistency in it to overthrow your statement. (3) "i got plenty of examples if you guys need.. God destroyed whole earth and left Noah.. what you say about that.." Are we surprised? Certainly not. Isaiah 45:7 "I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD do all these things." So why should we be surprised? By the way, do not mention the Noah Ark again. It is a shameful failure of your God. His intention was to kill all the sinful human beings. He selected the Noah family of eight out of all the human beings. What was the result? As you said, he really killed all but the Noah family. But sin remains. So He picked up the wrong family. His original plan and intention failed miserably, except the killing part. (4) "when people sin they will have to punished.. did you read why god didsuch "ungodly" thing?.. i bet you didnt.. so think before you commentthings.. seriously" Again what makes you think that we had never heard of your old argument? If your child sins, would you kill your child and burn him/her for ever? Ask yourself seriously: Where does sin come from? Why did your God allow sin get into this world, even though He knew well beforehand the consequence of it? Forget about that bullshit of "free will". When your infant child crawls towards a cliff and you know that your child will fall over, would you stop that from happening or would you just say: it is the child's free will to fall over the cliff? If it is the latter, I would say that you are, at the best, an irresponsible parent. [ 本帖最後由 ctaya 於 2008-9-3 21:29 編輯 ] | |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-3 00:11 發表 (1) "God punish human beings because of their sins.. you ever wonder why?.. " Please refer to my previous reply. (2) "you ever thought because of love?.. i bet not.." You do not call killing millions or even billions of human beings "love" and then put them into everlasting torment as "love". You may need to make your own dictionary to justify that. (3) "i bet your parents punish you when u steal right?.. because they love you.. no?" Would you expect my parents kill me, and then put me in an oven to roast forever? Come on. You must be out of your mind to come up with this kind of analogy. You need to see a psychiatry if you think that this analogy is appropriate. | |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-3 00:31 發表 You are a sick man. Do you mean that if a son does not accept a father, the father should kill him and torture him forever? No wonder there have been so much human sufferings and so many killings in the name of Christianity. Not only your doctrines are sick; believers like you are sick as well. You speak as if there is no value in human lives. So emotionless. It is Protestant like you that make me sick. If you live in Hitler's time, you surely would be one of those throwing the Jews into the gas chambers in the name of your God. "Those who can get you to believe absurdities,can get you to commit atrocities." (Voltaire) How true it is! | |
眾耶徒三朝唔埋就話我地唔睇耶經唔明耶經,其實好唔好先搞清楚一件事,唔接受,係唔代表唔明白/無去理解過架.正如有人教仔用口,有人用手.但我總可以就一口咬定話用口果個就一定唔識用手果喎,反之亦然. 將個問題又回歸返最原點,其他人我唔知,我就唔係話阿老耶做過D乜令人咁唔接受,而係唔認為真係有老耶囉.如果都無呢家野既,咁耶經上既咪都係同西遊記既一類小說咁囉,多多假少少真咁又話出書咯. 點都好,寫果班傻信果班就仲痴,教仔用口用手都多,但邊有話用超必教仔架,教完一次個仔都死諗咗,咁不如一早戴套又或者顏射,唔好鬼生佢出黎吧啦.學沙兄話事解,真係五餅三魚呀.... | |
最近我和幾個耶徒傾談, 我談及我很多年前已經離教, 其中一個教徒感到很驚訝, 另一個更直說我以前一定不是一個虔城的教徒. 也不用了解我的過去, 一眼就看出我不虔誠. 基本上他們的思維很簡單, 創造一套自己覺得理所當然的理論, 硬塞給你就是. [ 本帖最後由 山人乙 於 2008-9-3 22:08 編輯 ] | |
原帖由 Guest from 123.2.245.x 於 2008-9-2 23:23 發表 any way , ThANKing for your teaching , welcoming | |
原帖由 山人乙 於 2008-9-3 21:33 發表 最近我和幾個耶徒傾談, 我談及我很多年前已經離教, 其中一個教徒感到很驚訝, 另一個更直說我以前一定不是一個虔城的教徒. 也不用了解我的過去, 一眼就看出我不虔誠. 他們，男 ?? 女 ?? ThANKs | |
原帖由 山人乙 於 2008-9-3 21:33 發表 最近我和幾個耶徒傾談, 我談及我很多年前已經離教, 其中一個教徒感到很驚訝, 另一個更直說我以前一定不是一個虔城的教徒. 也不用了解 could u share some of your 過去 or your 離教 experience ?? but , please , please dont leak out your privacy , ThANKs ps : ::::: sorry can not write u out in Chinese [ 本帖最後由 prussianz 於 2008-9-6 02:53 編輯 ] | |
(2) Prof. F. F. Bruce 當然是人，我只是想帶出參考資料的可信性。我實在討厭和一些在信仰上沒有立場、只是人云亦云、左quote右quote 的人對話。(我想你們應該不是) (3)"如果你認為不了解耶神而信是沒問題的, 這不是一種謙卑的學習態度....." 我真的不認為有太大的問題。首先， 我覺得因為我不能全面了解全能的神 (好像我不知道不受時間限制看事會怎樣?怎樣才能令愛與公義並存?等等..) ，所以我唯有信，但這不代表我不追求對神的認識。我信是基於基督十架的愛和人生命的改變。 On the other hand, 我覺得如果要對神學有認識的人才能信，神的救恩就不是給所有人。 [ 本帖最後由 Mara但以理 於 2008-9-5 18:16 編輯 ] | |
原帖由 Mara但以理 於 2008-9-5 18:09 發表 一知半解而信都沒所謂 卻要要求不信的人「完全」理解耶經(而且所謂理解,還是教徒的定義之下的) 當教義存在著一個矛盾的時間,就要求外人投入更多的信心,花更多的時間 塞一堆同樣矛盾,或者隨時更改的神學出來 有趣的是,相反,一知半解而信亞拉,黃大仙或者是宙斯的人,偏偏是種罪過。 到最後這是一種典範缺憾所造成的標籤錯覺：所謂的「不信不是源於不理解就是源於人性的自私」。 | |
| |
我唔信黃大仙因為我一點都唔覺佢有神的形象，佢唔保守我，我可以連香都唔俾佢食。 我唔信宙斯因為佢同我既生活一點都沒有關係。 而你又認識亞拉、穆罕默德有幾多? 我信基督耶穌，因他是唯一宣稱自己為神而且充滿知慧、慈愛、神跡奇事、勝過死亡的人。我愈看聖經，愈覺得耶穌既thinking 一點都唔似人既thinking，真的像神在說話、教導。 Sorry，我不覺基督教教義有什麼矛盾的地方。亦不覺得自己以迷信的心態來信神。只是我會覺得信是因為接受、明白神對你既愛，而不是因為對神了解有幾多。 | |
good point.. there is no way us limited human beings can completely understand unlimited God | |
we are born with nothing.. and we take nothing with us after we die. our body will go back to the ground after all... but its for God's love that we become valuable and have hope anyway.. i don't think i will convince anything Protestant? i am not sure if im that.. but im sure im a God's child. i believe in the bible because its not absurdities.. so i'll not commit atrocities..  good luck with your antichrist-ing there were only 120 believers after Jesus died on the cross how many there are now? 1 John 2:18-22 Dear children, this is the last hour; and as you have heard that the antichrist is coming, even now many antichrists have come. This is how we know it is the last hour. They went out from us, but they did not really belong to us. For if they had belonged to us, they would have remained with us; but their going showed that none of them belonged to us. But you have an anointing from the Holy One, and all of you know the truth. I do not write to you because you do not know the truth, but because you do know it and because no lie comes from the truth. Who is the liar? It is the man who denies that Jesus is the Christ. Such a man is the antichrist--he denies the Father and the Son. God bless you all.. |
| [1] < [7] [8] 9 > [10] |
[/url]