離教者之家

提摩太後書可能不是保羅寫的

kam 2023/5/17 18:40
Some modern critical scholars argue that 2 Timothy, as well as the other two so-called 'pastoral letters' (1 Timothy and Titus), were not written by Paul but by an anonymous author, sometime between 90 and 140 AD.[8][9][5] Some scholars refer to the assumedly pseudonymous author as "the Pastor".[5]

The language and ideas of 2 Timothy are notably different from the other two pastoral epistles yet similar to the later Pauline epistles, especially the ones he wrote in captivity. This has led some scholars to conclude that the author of 2 Timothy is a different person from that of 1 Timothy and Titus. Raymond E. Brown proposed that this letter was written by a follower of Paul who had knowledge of Paul's last days.[10]

Most scholars, both those arguing for and against its authenticity, are of the opinion that 2 Timothy belongs to a pseudepigraphic genre known as the testamentary genre or farewell discourse, the 'testament' genre contains two main elements: ethical warnings to be followed after the death of the writer and revelations of the future. The significant fact about the 'testament' genre was not in its markers but in its nature; it is argued that a piece of 'testament' literature is meant to "be a completely transparent fiction".[11][12]

Jerome Murphy-O'Connor, however, argued that 2 Timothy was written by Paul and that the other two pastoral epistles were written by someone else using it as a model.[6]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Epistle_to_Timothy
beebeechan 2023/5/17 21:46
The language and ideas of 2 Timothy are notably different from the other two pastoral epistles yet similar to the later Pauline epistles, especially the ones he wrote in captivity.

我英文屎卦, 睇到搲哂頭...
一話「different from」.....二話就「similar to」..咁即係買大又買細?。

(抽水就會話: 你自己去質疑維基喇....)
旁觀者 2023/5/17 22:43
我英文屎卦, 睇到搲哂頭...
beebeechan 發表於 2023/5/17 21:46

中文重渣, 小學生都識嘅字你都未識!
抽刀斷水 2023/5/18 11:05
我英文屎卦, 睇到搲哂頭...
一話「different from」.....二話就「similar to」..咁即係買大又買細?。

( ...
beebeechan 發表於 2023/5/17 21:46



    呢度有幾件野:

A: the First Epistle to Timothy (1 Timothy)
B: the Second Epistle to Timothy (2 Timothy)
C: the Epistle to Titus
D: The Pauline epistles

段文係話:
B =/= A
B =/= C
B ~~ D

我英文應該差過你呢個番書仔喎。

返回首頁 | 登錄 | 註冊